No products in the cart.


Is It Education or Learning?

Is It Education or Learning?

We hear a lot about the failings of the education systems of the modern world. A large part of the failings, I believe, are that the present systems are geared toward instruction (including a large portion of indoctrination), and not toward learning. Learning is something we all do every day of our lives, whether we realize it or not. Instruction, or being taught, can have value if the learner is open to the instruction, but is useless if the learner has no interest, or only a little interest. Quite simply, we are open to instruction if the subject matter interests us.

Being told that we must learn English for this 45 minutes, and math for the next 45 minutes, followed by science, or history, is a poor way of learning. In this situation, if you have an interest in history, for example, then 45 minutes is hardly enough time to delve into the subject that interests you.

I liked, and was good at, history and math, while I disliked science and only had some interest in English, yet, I was a voracious reader of classic books and many Pulitzer and Nobel Prize winning authors. I couldn’t care less what the parts of speech were in the sentences I was reading. I understood what was being said and fully enjoyed being transported to the author’s world. (Just as a side note, my Mother was an English teacher.)

The simple fact is, that we all learn best dealing with a subject we enjoy. Now, if I enjoy the books of Ernest Hemingway, I might want to learn more about the Spanish Civil War, as he was there, and wrote vividly about it. This is how learning progresses. One thing leads to another. It is not about this is 4th period on Tuesday so we will teach science class. Learning is not the same as instruction/teaching. Learning is something deeper, and far more important.

Below are some videos, (surprisingly, all of them TedTalks), about homeschooling and the act of learning.

How will I educate my children – Joshua Steimle

[ot-video type=”youtube” url=”″]

How School Makes Kids Less Intelligent – Eddy Zhong

[ot-video type=”youtube” url=””]

What if students controlled their own learning? – Peter Hutton

[ot-video type=”youtube” url=”″]


Shorty Dawkins



  1. Today, 3-15-17, I read an article on the net about a Professor Leslie Soodak from Pace University, who wants to do away with the Teachers Reading Test in NY State, because it’s “racist”, she says. She postulates that because some races have lower scores on the test given to certify teachers, that the test somehow discriminates against those teachers of certain races. I suppose that she has never heard of “remedial reading classes” that anyone could take before taking the exams ? Her complaints go even further using the race cards. It seems that she thinks that the student body is now less white, so white teachers no longer need apply for teacher jobs. No doubt she belongs to the Pepsi generation, as her head is all filled up with fizz.

    1. Until we kill the cancer that is Federally-controlled “Public Education”, we will continue to dig our own graves. Period.

  2. When I came out of college at 46, several friends asked “are you any smarter now?” I would answer, “no, but I am educated.”

Comments are closed.